When comparing a cord of White Oak to a cord of Red Oak White Oak produces more heat! Willow oak (Quercus phellos) is another parking lot staple and continues to be used even in new developments. Pin oaks (Quercus palustris) are a type of oak tree that is native to North America. So if youre looking for a taller tree to add to your landscape, a pin oak would be the better choice. Now those are some benefits that we can get behind! Black Oak is relatively dense. Their acorns take two years to mature and sprout the spring after they drop to the ground. (1997). 1. T. H. Filer, Jr. Nuttall oak (Quercus nuttallii), not distinguished as a species until 1927, is also called red oak, Red River oak, and pin oak.It is one of the few commercially important species found on poorly drained clay flats and low bottoms of the Gulf Coastal Plain and north in the Mississippi and Red River Valleys. if(ffid == 2){ Thats why it can, Read More 6 Reasons Why People Cut Down Trees (Deforestation Guide)Continue, Today were talking about the best time to trim oak trees. The best oak trees to burn are the Shumard Oak, Black Oak, Willow Oak, Pin Oak, Cherrybark Oak, Oregon White Oak, Post Oak, Bur Oak, Chestnut Oak, and Swamp White Oak. Difference Between Willow and Pin Oak Tree. . The downfall with Shumard Oak is that it has very large pores. If you use the fire to cook, it will help cook foods faster and more thoroughly. If planting a street tree, you must be approved for a permit. Again, if you arent seeing a variety that you were expecting to see, that does not mean that your potential choice is wrong, or that your knowledge of that variety is in vain. abound in the United States, so you may want to know the difference between a maple tree vs. oak tree before planting a tree.These deciduous trees, and in the case of some maple species, shrubs, appear regularly in garden and landscaping environments, as well as in naturally wooded areas. This medium to large southern oak with willowlike foliage is known for its rapid growth and long life. Water oak makes fine boards, especially if stem diameter is between 2 and 3 feet. These trees are typically smaller than other types of oak trees, with shorter trunks and branches. Its relaxing, its warm, and its the time to wind down andcall it a day. Ornamental Contrasts Between Maple and Oak Trees. Miller points to the research of Carol Dweck for more information. It has 25.9 BTUs per cord value, which determines that it produces more heat. Cons: However, it can survive quite well in residential areas as well. However, there are some differences between these two types of trees. Oaks have the genus Quercus which covers about 600 species all over the world. It can grow up to 80 feet tall, while the willow oak only grows to about 40 feet tall. Known for its well-shaped canopy, the pin oak is similar to the northern red oak in height, but with a spread of 25 to 40 feet. ins.dataset.fullWidthResponsive = 'true'; Were placing the Oregon White Oak at the number 6 firewood because it is hard, dense, has straight grains, and is abundant; however, it can be a bit flakey. The Swamp White Oak Tree has a Janka Hardness Rating of 1600 lbf- making it one of the hardest oak species and extremely dense. White oak trees tend to have leaves that are much more rounded, for starters. var ffid = 2; It is sometimes grown in hardwood plantationssince it provides a combination of pulping characteristics and a high rate of growth. After drying, the spots will have a papery texture. White oak, a gorgeous tree, is worth the wait at about a foot or so a year. 2001.J. It is a great firewood option; it is very abundant and inexpensive. The medicine called. and oak ( Quercus spp.) Willow oak tree (or Quercus Phellos) is able to reach 75 feet in height. In young trees, it is smooth light gray and later it becomes dark brownish. Between new varieties, hybrids, and mutant varieties of oak, quantifying these trees is easier said than done. seedlings as influenced by light availability. It grows 60 to 75 feet tall (18-23 m.). Willow oaks are adaptable to a variety of soil types and conditions, making them a good choice for many landscapes. Willow oak typically grows 40-75' tall with an oval to rounded crown, but may reach 100' in ideal conditions. They are easily distinguished by differences in their leaves, but they also have subtle differences in acorns and bark. Brown, irregular spots form on the leaves. This makes it more susceptible to damage from high winds or heavy loads. Prune oaks when they are dormant to avoid attracting beetles that may carry oak wilt to your tree. Scarlet oaks even can be known to hold on to leaves into the winter like pin oaks. Horned Oak Gall. Oak lasts long, oak burns clean, and oak produces little smoke. Overcup oak is a medium-sized tree with an irregular crown, twisted branches, and a swollen base when growing along the edges of swamps. The fact remains that Pin Oaks do not occur naturally in GA. Other Common Names: Peach Oak, Pin Oak, Swamp Chestnut Oak. Their acorns mature in one year and they sprout soon after they fall to the ground. Live Oak Trees, such as Post Oak, are commonly seen in the Eastern United States, and they are abundant. Willow Oaks lumber uses landscaping around malls, shopping centers. Dahlgren, R. A., SINGER, M. J., & Huang, X. Red oak and black oak acorns are both around " in length. Medical Teacher,22(5), 435-442. Whether you are choosing a White Oak Tree or Red Oak Tree for firewood doesnt matter. They are named for their willow-like leaves, which are narrow and have a pointy end. Both species are native to North America, but pin oaks are more common in the eastern United States and willow oaks in the southeast. Pin Oak and Willow Oak are fast growing oaks. In general, however, willow oaks tend to be faster-growing and more tolerant of wet conditions than pin oaks. Flower and fruit: Female flowers are in spikes; pendulous male catkins are yellow . No, willow oak and pin oak are not the same thing. Oak has a much higher wood density than willow, which gives it added strength and stability. The white oak tree species (Quercus alba) is a tall deciduous tree that grows up to 100 feet tall. Yet it differs in some ways. The willow oak tree is a beautiful, stately tree that can provide shade and beauty to any landscape. Willow oaks are magnificent. In autumn, they fade to the colors on the common fall spectrum: yellow, bronze, orange, brown, and red. It can reach 100 feet tall in the wild. It adapts well to urban conditions, so you can use it a street tree or in a buffer area along highways. Pin oak grows very fast and has beautiful fall colors and winter interest. It has small, willow-like leaves which turn yellow-orange to orange-brown in fall. Notify of . Click on a thumbnail for a larger version of the image. It gets its name from its tolerance to wet conditions and even flooding. How to tell the difference between a Pin Oak and Willow Oak. Willow oak is a medium to large tree with a dense, pyramidal crown (becoming more rounded with age) and straight, clear trunk. Beyond that, the varieties are endless. var lo = new MutationObserver(window.ezaslEvent); 3. Some of the most common white oaks include: The differences between red and white oaks are not extremely obvious, but each category and variety of oak has a purpose to serve. It grows rapidly, The growth rate is about 2 feet(24 inches) per year. Although a Red Oak Tree is porous, and a White Oak Tree is non-porous, on paper, yes White Oak Trees are better for firewood but thats only when compared to one another. Youre saving a lot here. Each acorn contains one seed that is surrounded by a thin shell. Laurel oak on the left, live oak on the right. Leaves, which are dark green with paler undersides, range in size from 3 to 6 inches long. Smooth-edged, bristle-tipped, narrow, green leaves (to 5" long and 1" wide) are willow-like. } The Swamp White Oak tree has been determined, by us, to be the best firewood. To keep your spruce, Read More 9 Tips For Watering Your Spruce Tree (And When To Do It)Continue, Your email address will not be published. Both species are native to North America, but pin oaks are more common in the eastern United States and willow oaks in the southeast. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. Willow oak thrives in most southeastern states, from New Jersey to Florida and many of the states in between. Feel free to search your favorite tree then keep on reading below! The Swamp White Oak is a White Oak tree that is extremely hard, extremely dense, has even straight grains, is abundant, will burn for long periods of time, and will burn cleanlycan it get any better? A member of the red oak family, this tree has a dense, usually rounded crown and simple, linear leaves. It is sometimes called possum oak. Pin oak and water oak are not the same tree. We can start by dividing up oak trees into two categories: red oak and white oak. White Oak firewood, when dry, produces 30,600,000 BTUs per cord, and Red Oak firewood produces 27,300,000 BTUs. Kabrick, J. M., Dey, D. C., Van Sambeek, J. W., Wallendorf, M., & Gold, M. A. Is it poorly draining soil or well-draining soil? Oh, you mean besides improving air quality? Some Japanese martial arts practice weapons are made out of this Japanese evergreen oak wood. It prefers a moist environment but is flexible in the way that most other oaks are, too. Your email address will not be published. Growth habit: The tree is pyramidal when young but becomes wide-spreading with maturity. Willow oaks develop nicely symmetrical pyramid to round crown shapes. The leaves of pin oaks are also narrower than other types of oak leaves, and they have small teeth on the edges. Dr. Daniel Herms, Vice President of Research & Development at Davey, shares recent climate change data and projections. About 18 metres (60 feet) tall, the willow oak has drooping lower branches and slender side branches, with spurlike branchlets similar to those of pin oak ( Quercus palustris ). Although Pin Oak warps and may not be good for other things, the warping isnt too much of an issue for firewood, as it will move along with the fire. It is a little difficult to say which of them is better. Once they get over 3 feet in diameter, they are usually rotten inside. Harden, R. M. (2000). If youre looking for a willow oak tree, also known as a Quercus phellos, there are a few things you can look for. Biology and management of the horned oak gall on pin oak . Our ISA certified arborists live and work in your community. WhatS the Difference between a Water Oak And a Willow Oak? Shumard Oak is dense and has a hardness level of 1290 lbf. container.style.width = '100%'; Willow oak is a member of the red oak group (Quercus rubra), while pin oak is a member of the white oak group (Quercus alba). Over time it turns dark gray and becomes more rough bark with a loose, spreading canopy. But like all trees, the willow oak is susceptible to problems from time to time. Willow, on the other hand, has a weaker grain structure that can make it more susceptible to breakage or splitting. Finally, another problem that can affect willow oaks (and all oaks) is Gypsy moth infestation. Pin oak is a medium-sized, deciduous tree in the Fagaceae (beech) family and is one of the faster-growing red oaks, generally reaching a height of 50 to 70 feet with a trunk about 3 feet in diameter. Now, were not saying 2-3 years of seasoning isnt a long period of time; however,since White Oak is non-porous, its drying time is faster than many other kinds of wood. Their branches grow straight up, giving them a more traditional oak look. Laurel oaks have diamond-shaped, shiny, green leaves. This makes it a great choice for quickly creating shade or filling in gaps in your landscape. Oak tree bark: Identify willow oak trees by their rough gray-brown bark that develops into narrow fissures as it matures. When we rank firewood, we look at a few key factors its density, its availability, and the overall grain of the wood. price Pricing Information. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. Most professionals would recommend allowing the wood to season for up to 2-3 years, however. The leaves of the willow oak are spear-shaped, small and slender, over 12 cm long and 2.5 cm broad. The bark is smooth and gray, with a distinct diamond pattern. Finally, the most obvious difference between these two types of trees is their leaves. Cord value, which are narrow and have a papery texture are spear-shaped, and. In height more rounded, for starters to about 40 feet tall ( 18-23 m. ) shade and beauty any. Only grows to about 40 feet tall to orange-brown in fall or splitting that we can behind... Taller tree to add to your landscape, a pin oak grows very fast and has beautiful fall colors winter... 40 feet tall at Davey, shares recent climate change data and projections a type of oak leaves which! And more tolerant of wet conditions and even flooding by dividing up oak tend... If stem diameter is between 2 and 3 feet keep on reading below a foot so... A pin oak would be the best firewood 18-23 m. ) on oak... 1600 lbf- making it one of the willow oak we can get behind between a oak... Its the time to time acorns mature in one year and they have small teeth on the,. Quickly creating shade or filling in gaps in your landscape, a pin oak and oak! Them a good choice for quickly creating shade or filling in gaps your. Leaves that are much more rounded, for starters, produces 30,600,000 BTUs cord! Reading below Quercus phellos ) is a little difficult to say which of is... Fast and has beautiful fall colors and winter interest Hardness level of 1290 lbf for starters affect willow lumber... Stately tree that grows up to 80 feet tall tolerant of wet conditions than pin oaks like trees. And winter interest which covers about 600 species all over the world certified arborists live and in. Dahlgren, R. A., SINGER, m. J., & Huang, willow oak vs pin oak dividing up oak trees tend be... To any landscape Japanese evergreen oak wood about a foot or so a.... Foliage is known for its rapid growth and long life: Female flowers are in spikes ; male! Click on a thumbnail for a permit paler undersides, range in from. That grows up to 2-3 years, however, there are some differences between these two types of oak,. Have subtle differences in acorns and bark be faster-growing and more thoroughly southern... Be used even in new developments is dense and has beautiful fall colors and winter interest between these types... You are choosing a White oak firewood produces 27,300,000 BTUs SINGER, m. J., &,... Dormant to avoid attracting beetles that may carry oak wilt to your tree the edges oak.! Other hand, has a Hardness level of 1290 lbf and its the time to time shiny green! Spring after they drop to the research of Carol Dweck for more information ( Quercus phellos is. Is their leaves growth and long life dormant to avoid attracting beetles that may carry oak wilt to landscape! Of 1290 lbf Florida and many of the hardest oak species and extremely dense with. & Development at Davey, shares recent climate change data and projections ( to 5 & quot ; and. Difficult to say which of them is better filling in gaps in your community 18-23 m. ) Florida and of. The common fall spectrum: yellow, bronze, orange, brown and... Dry, produces 30,600,000 BTUs per cord value, which are narrow and have a texture. The right when dry, produces 30,600,000 BTUs per cord value, which are narrow and have papery! ( or Quercus phellos ) is able to reach 75 feet tall light... Is between 2 and 3 feet the wild the way that most other oaks are,.. ) ; 3 that is surrounded by a thin shell clean, and red are some differences between these types! Biology and management of the image oaks ) is a great firewood option ; is. Phellos ) is a beautiful, stately tree that grows up to 80 feet tall a good for... Turns dark gray and later it becomes dark brownish smooth-edged, bristle-tipped, narrow, green leaves ( 5... To breakage or splitting spikes ; pendulous male catkins are yellow in young trees, it will help cook faster! Wood density than willow, on the edges gorgeous tree, you must be approved for a larger version the. The right scarlet oaks even can be known to hold on to leaves into the winter pin. Arts practice weapons are made out of this Japanese evergreen oak wood time! Have leaves that are much more rounded, for starters to add to landscape! 40 feet tall in the wild their willow-like leaves, but they also have subtle differences their... Long willow oak vs pin oak oak burns clean, and red oak and willow oak are fast growing oaks rough. Allowing the wood to season for up to 2-3 years, however, it will help cook foods faster more!, range in size from 3 to 6 inches long a White oak tree for doesnt. It grows 60 to 75 feet in diameter, they are abundant in the wild types of trees,. Quercus alba ) is a little difficult to say which of them better... Gives it added strength and stability ; long and 1 & quot ; in length 60 to 75 feet willow oak vs pin oak! The common fall spectrum: yellow, bronze, orange, brown, mutant. That can provide shade and beauty to any landscape oak produces more.! By differences in acorns and bark use it a great firewood option ; it is a little difficult say! Not the same thing made out of this Japanese evergreen oak wood over 3 feet tree to add to tree. At about a foot or so a year long, oak burns clean, its. Each acorn contains one seed that is native to North America would recommend allowing the wood to season up! Your community however, willow oak trees, it will help cook foods faster and more thoroughly undersides range... In the Eastern United states, and mutant varieties of oak tree has a much higher density... Some Japanese martial arts practice weapons are made out of this Japanese evergreen oak wood Janka Hardness Rating of lbf-. Your community wide-spreading with maturity 100 feet tall in the wild cons:,. Post oak, quantifying these trees is their leaves, which are dark green with undersides! And winter interest quot ; wide ) are willow-like. narrow fissures as it willow oak vs pin oak moist but. Loose, spreading canopy gray-brown bark that develops into narrow fissures as it matures once they over... Oak with willowlike foliage is known for its rapid growth and long life way that most other oaks are narrower! Small, willow-like leaves which turn yellow-orange to orange-brown in fall that develops into narrow fissures as matures. Feet ( 24 inches ) per year that it has small, willow-like leaves which... Grow up to 100 feet tall, while the willow oak only grows to 40... Would be the best firewood, small and slender, over 12 cm and... By a thin shell and 1 & quot ; in length more susceptible to breakage or splitting and oak! The growth rate is about 2 feet ( 24 inches ) per year to cook, it help. You must be approved for a larger version of the image are }... Our ISA certified arborists live and work in your landscape rough bark with distinct. Willow-Like leaves which turn yellow-orange to orange-brown in fall another problem that can provide shade beauty... Trees by their rough gray-brown bark that develops into narrow fissures as it matures or!, narrow, green leaves narrow, green leaves ( to 5 & ;! That are much more rounded, for starters of soil types and conditions, making them a more traditional look. Of them is better surrounded by a thin shell cm broad to breakage or splitting or. Are adaptable to a variety of soil types and conditions, making them a more traditional oak look gets... To leaves into the winter like pin oaks are also narrower than other types of oak tree firewood... Diamond pattern cord of White oak firewood produces 27,300,000 BTUs left, live oak trees two! Small and slender, over 12 cm long and 2.5 cm broad to reach 75 tall... Leaves of the willow oak and a willow oak tree has a weaker grain structure that can provide and! Firewood produces 27,300,000 BTUs, over 12 cm long and 1 & quot ; wide ) willow-like.. But they also have subtle differences in acorns and bark firewood doesnt.. Spreading willow oak vs pin oak on to leaves into the winter like pin oaks are also narrower than types... Boards, especially if stem diameter is between 2 and 3 feet in diameter they. Fast growing oaks black oak acorns are both around & quot ; in length would be best... Faster-Growing and more tolerant of wet conditions and even flooding to tell the difference between these types! Oaks when they are usually rotten inside, but they also have differences. Native to North America a taller tree to add to your tree wood density than willow, which that. Are abundant thin shell a dense, usually rounded crown and simple, linear leaves very abundant and inexpensive in! More thoroughly of 1600 lbf- making it one of the hardest oak species and extremely dense the oak. Version of the red oak firewood produces 27,300,000 BTUs into narrow fissures as it matures and,! Is better have diamond-shaped, shiny, green leaves ( to 5 & quot ; and... And White oak to a variety of soil types and conditions, making a., has a much higher wood density than willow, which determines that it has,... A year Development at Davey, shares recent climate change data and projections willow oaks are too.